It's a definite no-no!!! I used this today on my curled lashes, and at first I thought this stayed pretty well on the lashes, but NO!!!! After an hour the 'small particles' from the mascara deposited on my undereye area, giving me racoon/panda eyes, and I had to swipe it away and reapply some concealer, and I did this a few times for the day! I didn't ask for waterproof, volumizing, lengthening from this mascara, but this is definitely a letdown even for an average mascara. Poooof, this is so going to the trash can!! (In fact, it already had gone to the trash can. I"m lucky enough that this is a sample that I have.)
So, stay away from this mascara!